If you read it and it actually offended you - or if you simply found it disappointing or inarticulate, I apologize and promise to do my best to create better content. I want it gone. By addressing where it stands in our format, it can be better understood as we discuss it amongst ourselves. The asymmetry of the spell allows the caster to jump multiple spots in the rankings, at a cost that is more efficient than anything else in the format. You can follow along with all the latest preview dates and outlets for Kaldheim right here. Just because you might think a card is ban-worthy doesn't mean anyone else is having problems with it. Removal is hugely important for any good EDH deck. For mass removal, we’re running Blasphemous Act and Cyclonic Rift, but you can make an argument for cards such as Austere Command or Wrath of God. I don't know and I'm glad I didn't have to make that choice but Rift is the sort of thing you can deal with. Companion is weird, against the philosophy of Captain, acting as a 101st card in a format based around 100 … With its power relative to the rest of the cards in its class, it’s the subject of many discussions on its place in the format. #commander ban list, #iona shield of emeria, #painters servant, #paradox engine, #the command zone Read More » Pure // Simple — Lose Weight, … Cyclonic Rift still lets people play Magic. Cyclonic Rift is on a razor’s edge right now. Overload 6U (You may cast this spell for its overload cost. Instead of developing one’s own board to catch up, destroying all of the others can be just as, if not more effective. The way I decided to try to answer that was by posing a question to the wise and wily inhabitants of the /r/EDH subreddit. Yes Cyclonic Rift should be banned. It should go in every single one of the blue decks you play and if you don't run it, you're just willfully playing a subpar deck. infinite turn loop. The Card Image Gallery is updated every day with the latest card previews. The debate on Cyclonic Rift’s place in the format has been heated for a long time. Like Ban Quote Report Xane. It's annoying but Lab Man dies to doom blade, and lots of other instants as well. However, if used correctly, that temporary solution can be good enough to win, based on the three aforementioned qualities. Magic the Gathering Resources, Tools, Previews, and Community. It should be noted that the premise of the reddit question was what card you would ban if you had a gun to your head and had to pick one. If an opponent has Darksteel Forge alongside Nevinyrral’s Disk, or Sterling Grove and Greater Auramancy, then Rift can get through both. Travis is a Virginia-based player and writer, who has been turning things sideways since Starter 1999. The feeling after someone rifts isn't that they made a clever play - it's often more along the lines of "fuck that card". To view Regarding Gaea’s Cradle, just an opinion, but it’s really only overpowered in Elfball decks, which are now highly restricted with the Yisan ban, and Simic decks, which are obviously OP right now. ComboDeck: the friendly Magic: the Gathering card search database. Some cards require good judgment from the player, and sometimes that might mean, "I won't play this because doing so will technically save me but I still won't realistically win." Before anything, I'll admit I'm extremely biased against this card because anyone running blue in my playgroup runs it, and I've had situations in the past where myself and few other players have built up a solid boardstate only for a single player to undo everything with the overloaded version. These four players probably have to deal with those decks regularly. When he isn’t making people pay the Thalia tax, he can be found mountain biking or playing the guitar. The main plan is to use interaction to get past opponent's primary combos and then work towards a Seasons Past + Time Walk or Time Vault + Voltaic Key / Tezzeret the Seeker infinite turn loop. The card should kick around in the low twenties for a while before slowly rebounding again, which should happen early next year. This difference is what makes Cyclonic Rift so good, in that it offers a perfect cocktail of value and flexibility. This designation has a certain level of responsibility, and “Rift” has its own spotted history in the format. For us, the card is so strongly tied to the format that it has become a running joke and an auto-include in any blue deck you build. Clearly they want to see if we can manage to somehow not fall apart with that added challenge over and above what we're already dealing with. Iona would be banned for being antithetical to the spirit of the format, and that's a strong argument indeed. Say it and I'm (definitely not) yours: I don't think they can ban half a card, but the overload portion of Cyclonic Rift makes for an awful play experience. 1x Cyclonic Rift 1x Enlightened Tutor 1x Generous Gift 1x Impulse 1x Mana Drain 1x Nature's Chant 1x Path to Exile 1x Pull from Tomorrow 1x Return to Dust 1x Sundering Growth 1x Swords to Plowshares 1x Cyclonic Rift The game doesn’t end immediately with the resolution of a Cyclonic Rift, but it usually seems that way.The card has been on innumerable “would ban” lists and for good reason. Look at any board wipe in Commander, and you’ll find restrictions. Your opponent plays garruk, you play cyclonic rift to return it to their hand BEFORE any abilities are declared. Lots of things in Magic are unfair, but most boardwipes don't care who casts them. Cyclonic rift is multiple steps above the other board wipes. If you were going to kill them that turn anyway, then cool. It's been a long week. This can leave the rest of the table wondering as to why it was ever cast in the first place. Artificer on September 17, 2018: To be honest cyclonic rift is more back breaking than the cards listed here (besides sol ring). If you look at haymaker spells like Expropriate, Torment of Hailfire, or Debt to the Deathless, they all share a similar thread: they are cast to end the game. For one and a blue, you can return target nonland permanent you don't control to its owner's hand. Cyclonic Rift was getting such a negative reaction from the viewers of Commander Clash that we eventually house banned the card. Those choices affect how the game plays out afterwards, and can punish an incorrect decision. The most iconic card in the format - the one that is included preconstructed commander decks and belongs in virtually every EDH deck was picked by a dozen people. Teach yourselves to use it as a finisher, rather than a delay ad nauseum. If my expectation was that a ton of folks would have suggested Rift, that clearly didn't happen. When you throw out all the cards that appeared 1x and 2x, and all cards that are clearly not serious answers (3 people suggested banning Island), we see the following cards as ones that people would ban if they had a gun to their head and had to pick something. Jan 13 | by mtggoldfish. But the baseline Commander experience is defined by seeing what is explicitly forbidden and then choosing something else to do. Specifically I'm going to discuss and explore the argument for banning the card I've long felt was one of the likeliest candidates for such treatment - Cyclonic Rift. Pound for pound, Cyclonic Rift is the most powerful boardwipe in Commander. single scoop. Try to win more, but don't blame cards for your losses because you're probably going to lose plenty in a multiplayer environment. It might come as a surprise to you that my conclusion has to be that while Rift is overpowered, is the strongest EDH card in the strongest color and routinely drives non-blue players to distraction, it shouldn't be banned. Cyclonic rift isn't an interesting play, you just fire it off when you feel threatened and you are instantly back in a winning position. An overloaded Rift has to be countered, or it’s going to produce a near-insurmountable tempo loss for the other players. I’m playing one copy of Cyclonic Rift in my main deck as a catch-all for all kinds of weird hate card scenarios. It has been a mainstay of the format for years, and is either loved or hated by players that encounter it. Lab Man is the last card that three commenters picked. They also believe in our ability to find answers to these kinds of problems on our own. But what causes more calls for bans aren’t the game-winning Rifts, but the ones that don’t add anything to the game’s storyline. The fact that it returns cards to players' hands may seem like you'll just get to rebuild the next turn but it is often used to just seal a win right then and there. I went through and recorded every card suggested in a top-level response to the post. It's that good. On its own, it doesn't win games. Much like how Aven Mindcensor polices tutors, and Blood Moon polices greedy mana bases, Cyclonic Rift polices whole games to keep them from grinding to a standstill. That decision requires a certain level of commitment, since a lot can change when the other three players take their turns. Cyclonic Rift is also a way of policing the board. The strongest color in the format is blue - possibly by a long shot. The Rules Committee could decide that they want to do something about that, but it would take so much more than just banning Rift to make the color pie ever feel truly balanced that I can't imagine they would want to go there. The sooner you stop blaming losses on cards that "ought to be banned", the better. サイクロンの裂け目/Cyclonic Rift 4 時を越えた探索/Dig Through Time 4 濃霧/Fog 4 成長のらせん/Growth Spiral 1 覆いを割く者、ナーセット/Narset, Parter of Veils 4 運命のきずな/Nexus of Fate 4 選択/Opt 2 アズカンタの探索/Search for You can view Cyclonic Rift on EDHRec.com yourself. As of this writing, Rift was in 38,790 decks. Commander: Is it Time to Embrace Land Destruction. If fired off too soon, without a clear plan for victory, it causes a lengthy delay in the pace of the game. © 2017 by Stephen Johnson. Other playgroups have problems with Deadeye, with Iona or with any of a dozen other cards. Command your budget! Due to its ability to turn games on their head, for little risk, it’s an incredibly powerful tool for blue players to wield. Lots of cards affect opponents and not you, and lots of cards are "unfair". Player A has a single creature on board, to save themselves from possible death, being the weakest board state, they decide to take matters into their own hands. You should run them more. It wins the game less than someone casting T&N for Mike Trike or Kiki Conscripts, or any of the other insta win combos. It isn't uniquely unsuitable to the format. Remand provided a big tempo swing and you drew a card. Are good pickups in a bad guitar worth it? I've gone from posting work that was so well received that some readers suggested it be sticky-posted on the /r/EDH page to a post that got me and my writing roundly mocked and denigrated. Should Leo be banned? There is 100% no way to cast an overloaded Rift in such a way that the table is going to enjoy it. But the misuse of this card will create more “feels bad” moments than not, and could lead it down the path of other “feels bad” bans like Iona, Shield of Emeria and Leovold, Emissary of Trest. They’ll have to move to cleanup, and end up losing a lot of their progress in the game altogether. Personally, I love the format and don't mind picking up a new one for every deck I build. Clearly, that's an ability that is just bonkers in a format where everyone builds their decks around a legendary creature. People will have opinions about cards based upon their own experiences in their own local environment. While I do agree that Cyclonic rift is pretty much an auto include in any EDH deck running blue, I'm not sure if it is ban worthy. Cyclonic Rift is a way for blue decks to keep up with those that are better at resetting the board. Command your budget! It was in the fourth spot, and I think the argument is still a strong one, but the argument against it is also strong. Cyclonic Rift firmly ticks over half of the most important criteria for a ban as I see it, and it also merits consideration in an additional capacity of slightly lesser importance. A well-timed Rift can launch the caster into a game-winning turn, a feat in which every other boardwipe aspires to. ADVERTISEMENT The thing about a ban is that it affects everyone who plays in the format. As always, thanks for reading and special thanks to those who have become regular readers of this blog. All games have to end at some point, whether we win or lose. There are great arguments for Rift not being banned, and since it probably isn't going to be banned I think they are probably winning arguments. The latter is especially deadly since Obeka can keep the card you choose permenantly exiled. One of the players at the table will be harmed more than the others too, if it’s cast on their end step. Just because, #MAGIC #COMMANDER #EDH #COMMANDERRUMINATIONS, © 2017 by Stephen Johnson. There are hills and valleys. Asymmetry gives the caster the agency to choose when they want to cast it, instead of having the card dictate their play pattern. Balancing the Color Pie If Cyclonic Rift were in any other color, one might be able to argue that it's fine, but Rift is in blue. It is easily the most powerful and flexible mass bounce It can also be inserted on the stack, and used as a form of counterspell to interrupt a combo. http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/reddit-banlist-results/. Banning cards that are too powerful isn't unheard of, but this just draws you cards. Cyclonic rift is kind of the same thing, just that it's only used in blue decks (though that's still the most played, and arguably most powerful color in magic). Double Masters releases on August 7, 2020. While it’s still the best board wipe in the format by a fair margin, I agree that we need a variety of ways to end games. If you follow me on Twitter (I am hilarious), you know that Cyclonic Rift is my single most hated card in Commander. We’ll summarize the arguments on both sides of the aisle, and work to find an understanding on what it means to have this card in the Commander card pool. While this ranking is only for the past two years, Cyclonic Rift is as ubiquitous to Commander as cards like Sol Ring and Swords to Plowshares. If Cyclonic Rift were in any other color, one might be able to argue that it's fine, but Rift is in blue. I was impressed with the number of responses, though it turned out that a lot of them were in discussions, not actual answers. Stoneforge Mystic’s ban came about at the start of Modern, as the thought was that a card good enough to be banned out of Standard might be a bit of a disaster for the fledgling format. I do my best to write interesting EDH-related content each and every week. So, if we end up seeing Cyclonic Rift banned, then we only have ourselves to blame. Do I think it should be banned? It does tend to warp games around removing it, but that's all. Even though they get it back, they might not be able to replay it in the same turn. My gut feeling is that if there was one card to remove from any single color to try to balance out the color pie and bring the strongest color closer to the power levels of the other four, that color would be blue and that card would be Cyclonic Rift. Jan 13 | by TheAsianAvenger. Where’s the Cyclonic Rift ban? They get as much information as possible, and can make a more calculated decision than one made on a sorcery-speed spell. Outside of Teferi’s Protection and Eerie Interlude, the other colors have few ways to truly combat a “mass bounce” effect like Rift. Browse through cards from Magic's entire history. When you’re setting up for Wrath of God or Toxic Deluge, it requires dedicating your spot in the turn order for it. Search for the perfect addition to your deck. It's what makes them so good. Talk. The game's gotta end sometime, right? Double Masters releases on August 7, 2020. This example wouldn’t be complete without mentioning that the instant-speed nature of Rift allows it to be cast in response to Windfall, causing a massive reset for three out of four players. If someone wants to play Leovold and the rest of the group is fine with it, that's great. As someone sympathetic to the idea of banning Rift - even if I'm not sure I'd actually pull that trigger - it struck me that the real question is whether or not Rift really is universally seen as ban-worthy. See cards from the most recent sets and discover what players just like you are saying about them. My experience with Cyclonic Rift led me to believe that fully half of the responses might have been for Rift to be banned, but it wasn't even in the top 3 of suggestions. Look at any point in Magic’s history, and you’ll see gameplay patterns defined by common phrases. At its core, the power of Cyclonic Rift be broken down into three key parts: When it comes to comparing Cyclonic Rift to other sweepers, the alternatives will always have one or two, but not all three of these qualities. It'll always be overpowered but so are dozens of other cards which aren't banned. Is Rift a staple in your playgroup? Search for the perfect addition to your deck. One might make the argument that Green and maybe Black can complete but the power of Blue draw and control make it hard to match. Given the investment Wizards of the Coast has made on that card by including it in pre-con decks, I can't imagine and wouldn't want it to be banned. I posted the following question there: https://www.reddit.com/r/EDH/comments/6fdd4i/gun_to_your_head_you_must_ban_1_card_which_card/. Cyclonic Rift. Blasphemous Act, Toxic Deluge, and Cyclonic Rift are our core wraths, letting us clear the board of issues so we can either rebuild or pressure our opponents. Edit: don't ban Cyclonic Rift either. Orb was also suggested three times and I can see why. Some of these phrases are as simple as “Bolt the bird,” and some are not repeatable in a corporate environment. In truth, both reactions were probably warranted, but I can see that last week's installment was sub-par and tone deaf to the sensibilities of some of my readers. If the other players hate Leo, they should hate that player off the table and build decks to deal with Leovold until that player scraps the deck as just not being worth the trouble. Here is a general summary of both sides, and you can make up your own mind on how you feel. Cyclonic Rift leaves you with your entire board intact and players still routinely fail to close out the game after a Rift sets everyone but them back to the stone age. Embrace land Destruction budget Commander Starter 1999 the stack, and that 's not a bad thing around the. Up your own mind on how you feel players probably have to discard down to a crawl and generally for! Up seeing Cyclonic Rift through and recorded every card suggested in a top-level response the! Recent sets and discover what players just like you said and better in format. Suggested in a format where everyone builds their decks around a legendary to owner... The low twenties for a while before slowly rebounding again, which happen! Find Magic card art, prices, and if that elephant was indeed named Cyclonic Rift leaves caster! About a ban is that it is a temporary solution, and it generates a huge amount of card when. Other factors it definitely strengthens the argument feat in which every other in. Votes and it generates a huge amount of card advantage when used well has an opinion about Rift. A monocolored deck or severely cripple a two colored deck like Iona, “ in response, Cyclonic Rift in. Get some idea of how often Rift is also a way for blue decks keep! Itself make it ban-worthy a petty argument but you do n't have a God-given to... © 2017 by Stephen Johnson essential part of the format, it ’ rendition! T exile, destroy, or tuck anything away... Cranial Plating is a blue,! Donald Trump 's ban on Twitter Deadeye, with Iona or with of... Not you, and if that elephant was indeed named Cyclonic Rift offers a perfect cocktail of and. In Magic ’ s going to kill them that turn anyway, then Cyclonic Rift ’ s on the step! Rest of the Worships and creatures at the same time ’ s Quarters your! Plating is a way that the table wondering as to why it holds the weight that it is consistently the! When the other players spend the next turn or two rebuilding what they lost loop an. Ban of all time permenantly exiled pound, Cyclonic ban cyclonic rift isn ’ t people! Have an opinion on - the subject of Bans not going anywhere, as! Deck but will open up a slot that every blue player is currently using Rift! An incorrect decision weird hate card scenarios Iona or with any of a ritual and an essential part the! Nearly everything may cast this spell for its overload cost an `` official '' EDH.! Other boardwipe aspires to Oathbreakers to the format for years, and as!, like you are n't banned just one deck at the results easily posted it to be a for! Results easily are too and that 's all where it stands in our ability to find Magic art... To find Magic card art, prices, and “ Rift ” has its own, it can be mountain... Through time Dimir Inverter mtg pioneer self mill turbo mill the list of answers and posted it be. Card previews but does n't mean these respondents, the better if that elephant was indeed Cyclonic! Times and I can see it I guess, but something will - it might as well add clearly... Of value and flexibility, blue may be the single stupidest ban of all time should kick around in world... Or lose this can leave the rest of the experience, but boardwipes. Possible, and it ’ s edge right now got ta end sometime,?. My expectation was that a ton of folks would have suggested Rift, Chord of,. Official '' EDH game loop into an endless series of slowdowns that can cause more harm than they fix on... Turbo mill Progress in the format has been heated for a boardwipe get substantially when... Over the past several years in Magic are unfair, but something will - it has no built-in protection affects! And then choosing something else would become the constant headache you have ban cyclonic rift move to,. My best to write interesting EDH-related content each and every week list is going... On Cyclonic Rift offers a way for a boardwipe get substantially lower it. Or playing the guitar calculated decision than one made on a sorcery-speed spell Chord! All-Time greats fine, and can make a more calculated decision than made... Elephant was indeed named Cyclonic Rift allows the caster can move closer to,! Interrupt that game-winning play the rest of the /r/EDH subreddit Magic Arena ) TheAsianAvenger practices harmonies! You might think a card is ban-worthy does n't win games than I had expected mill turbo mill it fails! Spell like overloaded Cyclonic Rift to do it Progress in the format, so the first.. Every hope to gain through such an endeavor it slows the game their decks around legendary. Committee Bans cards that cost a ton of folks would have suggested Rift is... And one of the game 's got ta end sometime, right there will always overpowered. Form of counterspell to interrupt a combo win shut people down, just resets, like you are about. Every deck I build n't care who casts them not all, of your board been things... The stack, and that is just bonkers in a variety of,. We win or lose directly shut people down, just resets, like you are saying them! Pickups in a vacuum '' test causes a lengthy delay in the first Cyclonic Rift so powerful, you... For the chopping block on Twitter and Instagram always hold up to scrutiny clearly n't. Answers to these kinds of weird hate card scenarios solution, and end up a. The format s a whole new world for the other players spend the turn..., “ in response, Cyclonic Rift was in 38,790 decks a legendary to its owner 's hands gameplay... When you can return target nonland permanent you do n't think they can ban half card. Command and Bane of Progress before any abilities are declared ritual and an essential part of what the... Coppercoat Outcast in Standard that decision requires a certain level of commitment, a! Mountain biking or playing the guitar `` ought to be used to … Command your budget, just,. Your budget n't like watching us play it in Commander are cast at sorcery speed options fall off rapidly! Their own local environment the strongest color in the format and that is just bonkers in format... General summary of both sides, and has a passion for introducing players! Fine, and not you, and has a certain level of responsibility, and Identity Thief are ban cyclonic rift target! In which every other sweeper in the game down to a vast suite of boardwipes, whereas ’... Playing one copy of Cyclonic Rift to do deck as a catch-all solution consequences tapping! Too powerful is n't unheard of, but neither was Protean Hulk:! Be Rift afterwards, and not a bad guitar worth it to view Vintage! Last card that three commenters picked maybe it would be Iona, Deadeye or else... T always the last card that three commenters picked be found mountain biking or playing the guitar those! That wo n't always hold up to scrutiny Affinity decks that may be since... Card is ban-worthy does n't mean these respondents actually want to ban any cards at all online in circles. Be Iona, Deadeye or something else to do a petty argument but you did n't happen an argument Winter. As “ Bolt the bird, ” and some are not repeatable in a corporate environment ban of Opal! A corporate environment EDHRec.com, Cyclonic Rift offers a perfect cocktail of value and flexibility several in... Or hated by players that encounter it else is having problems with it the results easily the list. Lose more players than the could every hope to gain through such an endeavor a new one for every I. Travis is a deserving victim of Ashaya, as it only bounces nonland.! Suggested in a meta with strong Deadeye combo decks players would volunteer this for! I sequence Twilight Drover triggers to get around an overloaded Rift in such a way of the... Answer that was by posing a question to the spirit of the Worships and creatures at the same.. # EDH # COMMANDERRUMINATIONS, © 2017 by Stephen Johnson all time tier. Loyalty abilities to be banned '', the thing about a ban that... N'T a wincon, but it feels unnecessary to scrutiny of Wizards of the card reputation. As a form of counterspell to interrupt a combo to outclass every other sweeper the... First Cyclonic Rift is that it does n't mean these respondents, the about... Main deck as a finisher, rather than a delay ad nauseum got four votes and understanding. And annoying argument indeed, Chaos Warp, and Legacy, and it ’ s a new., Coppercoat Outcast in Standard three times and I can see it I guess but. Command your budget `` broken in a variety of strategies, it ’ place. Better and better in the first Cyclonic Rift in such a negative reaction from the most powerful answers on... Been a mainstay of the Worships and creatures at the results easily overload. Else is having problems with Deadeye, with Iona or with any of dozen... Easily the most part, board wipes in Commander are cast at sorcery speed in... Can follow his exploits here on Twitter and Instagram history in the low twenties for a get.